Study: Young adults with history of school discipline report depressive symptoms, lower well-being

‘It’s time to rethink school discipline entirely,’ UB sociologist & study author says

By the University at Buffalo

Research on school discipline has focused largely on the effects of exclusionary measures across the life course, but a University at Buffalo sociologist has published a new study that suggests how a fuller range of disciplinary experiences, not just the most severe punishments, has detrimental health and well-being implications for students later in life.

The findings, published in the journal Emerging Adulthood, identified three distinct histories of discipline among college-educated emerging adults, a group unlikely to receive the most exclusionary types of discipline. This broader conceptualization of discipline, based on a unique sample of young people, demonstrates the need to think more expansively about the consequences of these disciplinary practices.

Suspension and expulsion are closely related to the school-to-prison pipeline, but the current study suggests the effects of these practices apply even to those who make it to college, not in the form of criminal justice involvement, but in terms of poorer health.

Avoiding the negative outcomes associated with these punishments, while creating an environment conducive to learning, requires understanding the effects of discipline beyond punitive methods, according to Ashley Barr, Ph.D., an associate professor of sociology in the UB College of Arts and Sciences, and the study’s corresponding author.

“The current generation of young adults came of age as schools began pulling back on zero-tolerance policies, but racial, class, gender and ability disparities remain,” Barr said. “It’s time to rethink school discipline entirely. Narrow conceptions of exclusionary discipline, limited to expulsion and suspension, don’t capture most of the disciplinary practices experienced by students.”

Barr and her co-author, Zhe Zhang, a doctoral candidate in UB’s sociology department, used survey data drawn from over 700 college-educated young adults who were categorized into three groups: Those who were minimally disciplined; those who experienced school-managed discipline, like loss of privileges, written reprimands or in-school detention; and those who received intense discipline that was likely to involve parents, counselors or law enforcement.

Participants with a history of school-managed discipline reported more depressive symptoms and worse self-rated physical health than classmates who were minimally disciplined. Young adults who experienced intensive discipline reported worse self-rated physical health than those in either of the other groups.

“Our analysis shows that the disciplinary histories of this relatively privileged group of college educated participants did not break down into a simple dichotomy of exclusionary and non-exclusionary,” Barr said. “Although this finding could be due to the privileged nature of the sample, it is consistent with other research suggesting that most school discipline is not what we typically consider exclusionary, and that discipline often begins with school-managed measures, and proceeds, often more quickly for students of color, to exclusionary measures.”

These disparities demand attention, according to Barr.

“Even in this college educated sample, we see dramatic disparities in who received intensive discipline,” she said.

Barr encourages other studies along this same research line using a nationally representative sample.

“Assuming the findings are replicated, I think disciplinary practices need to stay on the radar in school policy discussions, beyond the rollback of zero-tolerance policies” she said. “We need to use evidence-based practices in school for making sure that we’re attentive to the ways that our disciplinary practices are perceived by students. What’s supported by the data is that students consider exclusionary practices much more broadly than schools consider those practices, and this is evident in health outcomes.”