Here it is, our Haddock Hall of Fame!

Each Easter season, Niagara Frontier Publications seeks out the “Best Fish Fry” in Western New York. We ask readers to tell us which restaurant or social club offers the freshest catches, tastiest batters and most significant sides – customer service and price counts, too.

Though dozens of eateries have been nominated, only five have claimed the prize. Two restaurants – Grand Island’s The Beach House (3) and Lewiston’s Apple Granny Restaurant (4) – have won multiple titles.

Read more about the past winners below – and don’t forget to vote in the upcoming contest!


Village Inn is tops in 'Best Fish Fry' contest

Apple Granny Restaurant is 4-time 'Best Fish Fry' contest winner

Best Fish Fry 2020: Apple Granny wins 3rd title

Apple Granny defends title; named 'Best Fish Fry' in Western New York

Hometown News

View All News