Even a hurricane, or two, can't stop regrowth in parts of the coral forest

But other parts of these Caribbean ecosystems continue to decline, and one species cannot simply replace the other, says UB researcher

By the University at Buffalo

Soft corals at three sites in the U.S. Virgin Islands were able to recover from the destructive effects of nearly back-to-back Category 5 storms in 2017, but the story of these apparently hardy communities of colorful marine life is part of a larger, rapidly shifting narrative surrounding the future of coral reefs, according to a new study led by a University at Buffalo marine ecologist.

The recently realized resilience of the soft corals is an important development toward our increasing understanding of these complex ecosystems, but the findings published in the journal Scientific Reports puts that seemingly good news in the context of an ecosystem that is dramatically changing.

“These soft corals are resilient,” says Howard Lasker, a professor in the department of environment and sustainability and the department of geology, and an expert on the ecology of coral reef organisms. “But right now in the Caribbean we’re seeing a drastic decline of stony corals, and the soft corals are not a simple replacement for what’s being lost.”

[Click here to watch a video of both healthy reefs and reef damage.]

Soft corals, also known as octocorals, are branching colonial organisms. The colonies with their impressionistic tree-like appearance sway in ocean currents like trees in a storm. The stony corals, which also form colonies, produce rigid skeletons and create the framework of coral reefs. The living animal sits atop the structure they create, slowly secreting calcium carbonate, essentially limestone, to build up the reef.

These screen saver favorites are inspiring tourist destinations that, on a more practical level, play diverse ecological, economic and environmental roles, everything from protecting shorelines from erosion to providing habitats for a diverse populations of marine life.

The soft corals are doing fine while the stony corals have declined as much as 40% in recent decades, according to Lasker, whose team examined three reefs on the south shore of St. John (part of the U.S. Virgin Islands) following Hurricanes Irma and Maria, storms that passed within two weeks of one another in September 2017. They compared data from the storm’s aftermath with sampling that began in 2014 and continued in 2018.

“The octocoral communities we studied suffered dramatic declines with the passage of these hurricanes. In that sense, they weren’t resistant to the effects of severe storms,” Lasker says. “However, they showed resilience – the ability to recover.

“We found that many colonies were killed, but two years later it hadn’t changed the nature of species distribution, and as importantly new colonies were developing making up for the losses,” Lasker says.

This pattern of loss and recovery was emblematic historically of stony corals, as well, but that’s no longer the case for the scleractinians. Lasker says their soft coral counterparts, while providing shelter for many reef animals, will not build the hard physical structure of reefs.

“One of the big questions in marine ecology is what we should be doing,” Lasker says. “Should we be trying to remediate the damage and attempt to prevent species loss by creating protected environments?”

There is a range of opinions about taking the curator’s approach to the reefs, but what is certain is that these systems are already dramatically different from descriptions made during the 1950s. And those observations from the ’50s stand in obvious contrast to what European explorers would have seen when they encountered the reefs centuries ago.

“Humans are responsible for the changes,” Lasker says. “It’s really pretty simple: land use, sediments, sewage, agricultural runoff, overfishing, and now climate change.”

As the stony corals wane, the soft corals are replacing them, but the reason the stony corals aren’t recovering comes back to us, according to Lasker.

“It’s important to recognize that the resilience we’re seeing in these communities may decline with the frequency and intensity of future storms,” Lasker says. “This could be a temporary state. “The real test will come when we examine these areas 10 years down the road.”